The Buchenwald memorial. Photo: Photo: FaceMePLS / flickr CC.
How should we remember Buchenwald?
Nick Tyldesley believes that we should not expect easy answers to examples of tragedy
The city of Weimar is a cultural historian’s dream. It is chock-a-block with elegant, pastel coloured eighteenth century buildings in the classical style. There is the obligatory Schloss and along the cobbled streets are coffee shops offering a mouth-watering selection of cakes. Weimar is the cradle for German literature as both Goethe and Schiller lived and wrote there. A museum of Bauhaus art is opposite the main theatre. Hitler regarded the town as one of his favourite places. On the way to the station there are some public buildings from the Nazi era, shorn of their insignias, designed in an ersatz classical style. But no one wants to rent this available office space today.
In the woods
Up the hill and three miles out from the centre, nestling in the beech woods, is the death camp of Buchenwald. During the war the citizens of Weimar claimed to be blissfully unaware of what was going on in the woods, though they saw the smoke from the crematorium drifting through the trees.
On a cold April day, with the snow still deep on the ground, I visited this site as part of a conference on how we teach difficult issues in modern history. The setting was deceptively peaceful – the mist hovering through the trees and the dew were visitors disturbing the silence. The raw red bricks of the crematorium starkly intrude into this scene.
Having visited a number of similar sites, my way of trying to come to terms with the memories is to divert from any group and wander off on my own, right away from noise and humanity. In the silence the ghosts from the past become real. A colleague from the conference, whose grandparents died in Buchenwald, was very uncertain about coming along but afterwards said that he found the experience ‘worthwhile’.
Holocaust tourism
There are a number of uncomfortable questions to raise about ‘Holocaust tourism’. I don’t need to see the museum and artefacts to inform me about the ‘Final Solution’ – I have a previous knowledge. So, why go along? Is it not ghoulish to stare at the killing wall where inmates were shot? Is anyone not going to be moved by the tragedy?
The wise educational officer who showed us around made a number of interesting observations: we should remember that, in fact, the camp was a noisy, busy place. Jews coped by telling jokes to keep up morale – they were not always passive victims. The current administration certainly don’t want a virtual reality tour to be developed or to have actors standing around to be interrogated by visitors (as they do at American revolution sites in New England). Some minimum repairs take place but the barracks are not restored like some National Trust property with authentic furniture brought back. At Auschwitz there is still an ongoing debate about letting the camp simply be taken over by nature so that closure can take place. The practice of taking every Polish school child to the site as a reminder of the past continues. The German army visits Dachau for the same reason.
Should we feel a sense of collective guilt, albeit at a distance, for the crimes of the past and is this just a convenient strategy for coping?
Difficult questions
One of the criticisms of the English National Curriculum at Key Stages 3, 4 and 5 is that there is a predominant emphasis on Nazi Germany and the war. Is it time that we moved on and recognised that there are other examples of genocide around the world that might also demand our sympathy? In Vietnam, however, the museums of genocide are generally dusty, neglected places. So, should we enforce a sense of historical guilt on the young?
There are no easy answers to these questions and do we want to lose a sense of our historical roots on the grounds it was simply a long time ago? Sometimes we do need a jolt out of our complacency. Angkor Wat in Cambodia fights a constant fight against the encroachment of the jungle but battles to stop a total take over. If nature succeeded then something precious about human achievement will have been lost forever as a physical reminder. However, we might remember that buildings per se are not important, but people are: focusing on the stories of those who were part of the Buchenwald community would connect with a respectable tradition of reinforcing memories that goes right back in history. Empathy does go hand in hand with documentary evidence.
I think at Buchenwald they have got it just about right – minimum restoration and let the site speak in its own way. We shouldn’t expect easy answers to examples of tragedy. Silence and the appreciation of human noise can coexist.